Skill seemed to be a bit hit and miss. Some had negative skill for very minor infractions but there was no difference between that person and someone with a grievous infraction. They both ended up with one blue square and were looked upon negatively. I can only imagine the amount of admin and headache this system caused.
Could you not "police" through the report a post function? Amend the rules to include an escalating path for infractions? x number of infractions results in 1 day in the sin bin, 2 days, week, month, all the way up to a permaban?
__________________
|