I appreciate your wanting to get our opinion, but part of me has this feeling that you're going to your next game... picking you cards... and then saying "But the Softball Guys on CalgaryPuck.com said you shouldn't have a problem with this."
I don't think I've played on a team that was skilled enough to need this form of fielding, but we have played on teams where there's the pro who slams the ball out of plain sight every time he steps to the plate. Always pissed me off.
I think it's a great idea if it's rec, and I don't think I'd be insulted if a team I played against did it to me. I don't understand the concept of being beat bad vs. being beat by a sub effort. Then again, isn't Runs For/Agains usually a tie breaker? Aren't you just hurting yourself?
__________________
|