I think if you're looking for something specific, a place like Premier Sports in Marlbrough may be the best shot. Places like Jersey City don't carry smaller stuff like that. Otherwise, at this point, a week before Christmas, you may be SOL. People may watch NFL in Canada, but they don't buy NFL in Canada, and the bigger places wont carry smaller team stuff. Heck, they don't carry much for the Superbowl Champion Colts...
Most Jersey Citys carry NFL hats tho... odd that you didn't see them.
__________________
|