All time Jays: Your Final Roster

[JiriHrdina]

Catcher: Ernie Whitt (Backup: Pat Borders)
1B: Carlos Delgado (Backup: John Olerud)
2B: Robbie Alomar (Backup: Orlando Hudson)
3B: Kelly Gruber (Backup: Josh Donaldson)
SS: Tony Fernandez (Backup: Alex Gonzalez)
LF: George Bell (Backup: Shannon Stewart)
CF: Devon White (Backup: Vernon Wells)
RF: Joe Carter (Backup: Jose Bautista)
DH: Paul Molitor

Rotation
1. Roy Halladay
2. Dave Stieb
3. Roger Clemons
4. Pat Hengten
5. Jimmy Key

Bullpen:
Tom Henke
Duane Ward
Mike Timlin
Paul Quantrill
Casey Janssen

[JiriHrdina]

Found another all-time roster here (just for comparisons):
http://baseball.about.com/od/All-Time-Lineups/tp/Toronto-Blue-Jays-All-Time-Lineup.htm

Rotation: Clemons, Stieb, Hengten, Halladay, Key: Same
Catcher: Fletcher (BU: Whitt)
1B: Delgado (BU: Olerud): Same
2B: Alomar (BU: Hill)
SS: Fernandez (BU: Gonzalez): Same
3B: Batista (BU: Gruber)
LF: Bell (BU: Stewart): Same
CF: Wells (BU: Moseby)
RF: Bautista (BU: Green)
DH: Molitor (BU: EE)
Closer: BJ Ryan (WTF!!)

[Finger Cookin]

That team could do some damage.

1. White
2. Alomar
3. Molitor
4. Carter
5. Delgado
6. Bell
7. Fernandez
8. Gruber
9. Whitt

[JiriHrdina]

In terms of adhering to a 25 man roster, you've got the 9 man starting lineup+ rotation + penn for 19.
So six spots.
I give those to:
Borders (BU Catcher)
Hudson (BU Infielder)
Wells (BU Outfielder)
Donaldson (BU 3b)
Olerud (BU 1b)
Bautista (BU DH/OF)

Basically drop Stewart and Gonzalez

[Dion]

Thanks for doing those polls, Jiri. It's always interesting to see what members think on this forum.