All time Jays: DH

[JiriHrdina]

Who is the all-time Jays' DH.

[JiriHrdina]

Won't do a back-up for this one - just a single DH.
The DH position is Bizzaro land for the Jays. So many strange names. Canseco. Fullmer. And I think I had blocked out the fact that Frank Thomas was a Jay until this thread.

For me it is between two 1 year guys who were both so important: Winfield and Molitor. As much as I want to give it to Molitor, Winfield brought a veteran leader, demanded NOISE, and had the clutch hit in the decisive game to bring the organization their first WS.

[Strange Brew]

Went with Paul Molitor. Short time with the team but somewhat more of a favorite for me than Winfield.

But I think you are missing Cliff Johnson - he was Jays first DH that I remember and played that position for a few years IIRC.

[Derek Sutton]

Can we go Bautista as RF and put Joe Carter as DH? Gotta go with Molitor then.

[Sylvanfan]

Molitor easily. He was epic in the world series in 93. If you ask me him and Alomar set the table for Olerud to have that freak outlier season.

[tvp2003]

WAMCO. Nuff said.

[Enoch Root]

Molitor was one of the best hitters I have ever seen

[Jiggy_12]

Not that he would win, but Encarnacion could have been an option for the poll. Has put together quite a few nice seasons now. My apologies if he was in the 1B poll but I don't recall that he was.