Quote:
Originally Posted by Russic
Just so I'm clear ... You are arguing that the thing keeping back a game where you play as a nazi killing allies is over-saturation of the genre? Games have come a long way in the past few years, but that's reaching.
I think the market will naturally sort itself out. Once games that aren't titled COD start to fail they'll move on to bigger and better things.
|
I don't think that it is overreaching to say that Nazis are overdone. Nazis are the most overdone thing in all reaches of entertainment from movies to games which will invariably feature as part of their plots Nazis or Zombies or sometimes, even Nazi Zombies (Wolfenstein, Uncharted, etc...)
WWII is completely oversaturated in movies, film, videogames and even speaking only of the COD games, I guess as a console player you never played the original Medal of Honor Games and then the COD games (Infinity Ward started from developers splitting off from the Medal of Honor team) that started almost 10 years ago.
WWII Games from the Same Family
Medal of Honor: Allied Assault
Medal of Honor: Allied Assault - Spearhead
Medal of Honor: Allied Assault - Breakthrough
Medal of Honor: Pacific Assault
Medal of Honor: Airborne -
AWESOME
Medal of Honor
Medal of Honor: Underground
Medal of Honor: Frontline
Medal of Honor: Rising Sun
Medal of Honor: European Assault
Medal of Honor: Vanguard
Medal of Honor: Infiltrator
Medal of Honor: Heroes
Medal of Honor: Heroes 2
Call of Duty -
AWESOME
Call of Duty: United Offensive -
AWESOME
Call of Duty 2 -
AWESOME
Call of Duty 3
Call of Duty: World at War
Call of Duty: Finest Hour
Call of Duty 2: Big Red One
Call of Duty: Roads to Victory
Call of Duty: World at War: Final Fronts
Call of Duty: World at War: Zombies
And that's only two game series! If there was one way to do a search of the percentage of war games that were based on WWII, I think it would be an overwhelming amount and the majority of all those games have to do with killing Nazis with a few of them offering glimpses into the Pacific War.
There needs to be something different, if they aren't going to touch WWI, then at least offer more glimpses into the different facets of WWII. Why are there so few Italian campaigns? (There was was in COD2 I think). COD's strength is putting you via first person into interesting situations. The most interesting WWII gaming experiences I've had were in Call of Duty: United Offensive and Call of Duty 2 where they put you into more interesting situations as being inside a bomber as it flies over enemy territory and you are scrambling between the gun turrets trying to hold off the Luftwaffe. Totally different from the normal gameplay as you frantically try to survive as your plane is getting shot up and you are climbing around inside of it.
The other interesting experience was playing Darkest of Days where I actually got put into a concentration camp (obstensibly Auschwitz by the architecture). Things like this, where a game can cause you to relive history and feel a tinge of the brutal impact of things is really what is important.