Ended up going with the Shaw phone, just too good a deal and easy for the changeover, as we had a fairly complicated setup. The install went mostly well, and the switch over was quick. We also have awesome phones with touchscreens, and fancy features like call display, and voicemail to email. Ya, we were stuck in the 90's before. We will save hundreds per month, too.
Best part? Talking to Telus retention's and getting the sad "we are sorry to hear" shtick.
I'll try to post a review after we have some experience with it, but happy with it as of now. Voice quality is fantastic. Any questions, let me know.
Air Canada - We're not happy until you're not happy.
Telus - hold on tight, we're going in dry!