Quote:
Originally Posted by ricardodw
Is Bennett still ahead of Ehlers? why?
Since the all star game this year Ehlers is 16 pts in 23 games 19:11/game and +4
Bennett since the all star game is 14pts in 30 games -11 playing just under 15 minutes/game. Bennett has 3 games this year over 18 minutes... He has had no stretch as a top line player.
I guess you don't follow the jets that much.... Scheifele somehow has matched or bettered Monahan's very impressive stats in almost all categories
Monahan - Scheifele
toi 19:10 - 18:32
ppg .78 - .86
goals/game .33 - .41
Hits/game .5 - .7
GvA 38 - 35
TkA 55 -61
Blkshts/game .5 - .5
FO % 51.0 - 44.2
+/- -6 - +16
age 21 -23 Scheifele 19 months older
so Monahan has more TOI/gm and a better faceoff %.
Would you trade Monahan even up for RNH? Pretty sure the Jets wouldn't trade Scheifele for RNH even up either. Work it from there RNH would still be a top 3-5 pick in that draft and Scheifele is clearly better.
Scheifele might be #2 in that draft behind Johnny Hockey. Landeskog has had 2 years in a row that would be considered a huge disappointment if Monahan , Gaudreau or Scheifele had next year.
You are somehow able to compare Hamilton's unrealized potential with what Scheifele is accomplishing.
|
Just painful analysis once again. I think most GM's take Bennett and his 2 less points over Ehlers. Ehlers has jumped to 5th in a redraft today but your small sample size that barely supports your narrative is not enough to tip the scales.
What Schifele did for the first time in his career 5 years after he was drafted Monahan did for the second time 3 years after he was drafted.
Dougie at 22 has 2 straight seasons of 10+ goals and 40+ points. This is not potential these are results. Dmen take longer to develop but he has had very impressive seasons where Schifele is starting to show what he can be.
Johnny is a clear #1 in 2011 but there are several other players that would be in the mix for number 2. Schiefele is in that mix with Dougie, Saad, RNH, Huberdeau, Couturier