View Single Post
Old 11-08-2014, 03:53 PM   #5002
Drury18
Franchise Player
 
Drury18's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2003
Exp:
Default

Oling, let me entertain you briefly here. Because this is something else that's bothering me:

Let's say Dissentower is mafia. He's obviously not the Godfather. You tracked him, you caught him. Godfather would have been blocked.

You've tracked me, you saw I did nothing. You didn't get a block. I'm not the Godfather.

You didn't track Timbo, so we don't know if he's blocked. However the bucket role is reliant on him not standing behind someone who will be killed by the mafia otherwise he will be killed. This doesn't add up for him to be the Godfather, ordering hits, then "hiding" behind someone to see what happens and hoping he doesn't get killed. And he's produced confirmed results, so again, that's going to be alot of coordinating there that I don't think could happen. Also, if you are right, Starseed's power didn't work due to him being light.

You didn't track HG, so you don't know if it's blocked or not. When Timbo went behind him with the bucket, he got a double vote when Pux and Starseed put a single on HG15 (and again, my powers did not come with a caveat. I'm 100% sure that vote didn't come from me) . HG transformed your power and confirmed something you said, but no one has seen him do anything. His Master Sword (of which I can find no role, no explanation, no previous online mafia game that's ever seen a rewind so I can't even look up information to see what it is and where the alignment might be whether light, mafia or either) was a daytime use which would have shown him as having only a day power so it wouldn't make sense to send a tracker to view him, he was powerless due to a day action.

There has to be a mafia leader. The NHL Game had a godfather, the double mafia game didn't but it was a different setup by far. When you look up information about mafia games, most have the leader, the Godfather or something similar. That person would be blocked from investigation or come up town. We've flipped two mafia and have a Bus Driver and Watcher, neither really sounding like a leadership mafia role.

What if HG15 is the Godfather? You've investigated the other 3 of us and got results. We can't be that role.

He hammers Diss and takes out the partner, but he kills one of you, me and Timbo. Tomorrow goes with 2-1 and banking on the town to pick the right one whose scum. HG15 hammers scum so he's a hero. Chances are, the two town vote each other in some wild finger pointing contest, HG15 hammers whoever and wins.
Drury18 is offline   Reply With Quote